Update 6 January, 2008: The Mayor of SpellingCity has contacted me to say that they are hard at work on the bugs, and they look forward to seeing a better range of spelling lists on the site in the near future. We’ve been invited to return to the site in 60 days, to see the improvements. I promise I’ll let you know what I find when I make my return trip!
***
I found SpellingCity.com through another home education blog. As mentioned in that entry, this is a free web site offering tools for spelling - through learning, testing & playing games. There are free word lists for grades K-8, as well as Dolch words, large numbers, American States, and Harry Potter vocabulary, among others. To make use of the existing lists simply click the link for “sample lists”.
The site is set up for students, teachers & parents - with the ability for home educators to register as “homeschool parents/teachers”. You can use the site without having to register - for example print out one of the sample lists as an educator, or as a student search for your teacher’s lists and use the games as a fun way to learn words.
Registration is free, and minimally invasive (they ask first & last name, city, state/province, zip/postal code - this makes it possible for students to find teachers’ lists.) Registered users can store their own lists, and can also import lists from other users. It is possible to print lists and also word searches.
Does SpellingCity.com really live up to the quote on its homepage, that “This is already the best site out there”? Probably not, but it does offer some services that are worthwhile. Here are some of the pros and cons, so you can sort it out for yourself.
Pros:
- Teachers and students can enter their own lists or use those supplied by the site or other users;
- Three games are provided to teach spelling in a fun context: “HangMouse,” Word Search and Unscramble;
- Students can test themselves, and then work on any misspelled words using the “teach me” or “test me” functions;
- The “test me” function offers both the word itself, and a sentence containing the word;
- There is an audio & a visual component - this helps with learning for all students and makes it possible for younger students to work independently;
- Educators who need an ICT component may wish to include this site, among others;
- After testing, students can print out a pretty certificate to show their score - a nice incentive for the younger ones and a help for record keeping too!
Cons:
- Although there are both student & teacher or parent accounts available, there is unfortunately no way for a home educator to track student use or progress with this site (there may be such available with the teacher account);
- Links are not reliable, for example the “teach me” link frequently brings up the test instead of the teaching screen - the “check me” button on tests also sometimes doesn’t work, which can be frustrating even for an adult after having typed in close to 40 words;
- I found the audio didn’t buffer well at all - there were really long delays which could cause a student to click twice, resulting in two broken audio clips playing, one on top of the other (apparently this is a Flash-related issue for Firefox users) - and some of the voices were not terribly clear especially with shorter words;
- Navigation from one section of the site to another is not always intuitive - one must often return to the main page (not the same as “my homepage” in the navigation menu) in order to find the desired page;
- When entering custom lists, the list is automatically capped at 5 words and then each successive word must be added with an extra click to add the space;
- All custom lists are assumed to be public, and must be “unpublished” after creation - NB students can only search for public lists, as there is no way to allow only certain users to access a list.
Other than the above, my general feeling was that this site was not created by folks who know about spelling or language arts instruction. The list of “cons” is mainly bugs that can be worked out, or extras the site may one day choose to offer. What was of greater concern to me was the fact that the sample lists were far too long (37 words for the very first grade one list!) and were arranged alphabetically for each grade above Kindergarten, rather than according to phonics/word families or degree of difficulty. Some of the sentences associated with the words might be too complex or distracting, as well. When I entered the word “and” in a custom list (obviously for beginning spellers) the sentence it gave was, “He can walk and chew gum at the same time.” The sentence for “bat” felt like a third grade science lesson!
I would avoid using the sample lists for spelling instruction. I would also not use this site as a primary tool for spelling instruction, even if custom lists are entered.
Good uses for this site would be:
- To allow for extra practice, once words have been introduced with an instructor;
- As a follow-up to a spelling test, rather than the old standard of having students write out words they’ve missed a certain number of times;
- For older (e.g. adult literacy, or remedial) students will find it possible to input simple words and generate sentences which do not insult their intelligence;
- Once a student has covered a lesson, if their writing indicates they may have forgotten a spelling pattern, they can be directed to an archived lesson for review;
- Teachers and home educators may want to use the site to print lists or word searches, or also to share lists with one another.
Interestingly enough, among the games suggested for teachers (these are not all incorporated into the site yet) several originate on the BBC Schools web site, where you can find the Dance Mat Typing course I reviewed a few weeks back. I look forward to seeing more of these games integrated into the SpellingCity site, so they’ll function with the custom word lists. This would mean students could choose a broader range of activities for any given spelling list.
You might also find the following sites helpful for spelling instruction & practice:
Everyday Spelling
Scott Foresman - complete spelling lists for grades 1-8, printable puzzles, reference materials, links
Word Shapes Worksheet Generator
A to Z Teacher Stuff Tools - up to 12 words per worksheet
CanSpell & SpellIt! Spelling Bees
Both the Canadian & American bees offer online study zones with lists, lesson plans, puzzles, word of the day, links, etc.
BBC Schools Spelling
A selection of interactive activities that teach syllables, roots, prefixes, suffixes, homophones, etc.
NB: click on “Tutors” in any section for an overview of the module

This work was created by Ruby of Freehold 2, and is licensed under a
Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 2.5 Canada License.
Excerpts copyright quoted authors. Please visit their sites to read more, and respect the terms of their copyrights. Thanks!